Skip to content
Cyberphore

Privacy law and breach response

PHIPA vs PIPEDA: Which Privacy Law Applies to Your Clinic?

PHIPA vs PIPEDA for Ontario clinics: who counts as a custodian, where federal law still reaches, how breach duties differ, and a checklist to sort it out.

Published
Updated
Read time
5 min
On this page · 8 sections, 5 min read

If your clinic is run by regulated health professionals in Ontario, PHIPA is the law that governs your patient information, not PIPEDA. A federal exemption order removes health information custodians from PIPEDA, but only for collection, use and disclosure that occurs within Ontario, so information that crosses the border and businesses that are not custodians can still land under federal law. This is general information, not legal advice.

Start with One Question: Are You a Custodian?

PHIPA applies to "health information custodians." The first category on the list is "a health care practitioner or a person who operates a group practice of health care practitioners," and the list also covers pharmacies, laboratories, long term care homes and community health or mental health programs whose primary purpose is health care (PHIPA s. 3(1), Ontario e-Laws, consolidated from January 1, 2026).

A health care practitioner includes members of the regulated health professions who provide health care, and also "any other person whose primary function is to provide health care for payment" (PHIPA s. 2).

Federal law steps aside for those custodians. The exemption order says any custodian to which PHIPA applies "is exempt from the application of Part 1" of PIPEDA "in respect of the collection, use and disclosure of personal information that occurs within the Province of Ontario" (SOR/2005-399, Justice Laws, current to October 29, 2026).

Without that order, PIPEDA would apply: the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada (OPC) says health care providers in private practice "such as doctors, dentists and chiropractors are engaged in a commercial activity and thus subject to the Act, unless substantially similar provincial legislation applies" (OPC, 2015).

So the answer depends on who you are and where the information goes.

Sample screen; data is illustrative.

Six Situations Clinics Actually Run Into

These are generic examples, not findings about any real organization.

Situation (for example) Law that usually governs Why
A family practice, dental office or physiotherapy clinic in Ontario run by regulated professionals PHIPA The practitioners or group practice operator are custodians, and the exemption order removes PIPEDA within Ontario
The same clinic sends records to a provider or service in another province or country PHIPA, and possibly PIPEDA for that transfer The exemption covers only activity "within the Province of Ontario"; the OPC notes that disclosure across provincial borders may be subject to PIPEDA (OPC, 2020)
A gym or wellness company whose primary function is not health care Likely PIPEDA It is probably not a custodian, and PIPEDA covers personal information collected in the course of commercial activities (PIPEDA s. 4(1))
An EMR vendor or IT provider serving the clinic PHIPA rules for patient data; PIPEDA for its own commercial activity An agent's handling counts as the custodian's use (PHIPA s. 6(1)); a non-agent electronic service provider may use the information only as needed to provide the service and must not disclose it (O. Reg. 329/04 s. 6)
The clinic's own staff HR files Generally neither PHIPA excludes employee records kept for purposes other than their health care (s. 4(4)); PIPEDA covers employee information only for federal works, undertakings or businesses (s. 4(1)(b))
A clinic in Manitoba or Saskatchewan The provincial health law, and possibly PIPEDA The OPC lists only Ontario, New Brunswick, Newfoundland and Labrador and Nova Scotia as having health laws declared substantially similar; for other provinces' health laws, "in some of those cases, PIPEDA may still apply" (OPC, 2018)

Where the Two Laws Differ When Something Goes Wrong

Breach rules are where the difference shows most. If you hold data under both regimes, follow the stricter one.

PHIPA (custodians) PIPEDA (commercial organizations)
What triggers notice to individuals Any theft, loss, or unauthorized use or disclosure of personal health information (PHIPA s. 12(2)) A breach of security safeguards that creates a real risk of significant harm (PIPEDA s. 10.1(3))
Timing "At the first reasonable opportunity," with a statement that the patient may complain to the Commissioner "As soon as feasible" after determining the breach occurred
Regulator notice The Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario (IPC), in seven prescribed circumstances, including theft, unauthorized use or disclosure by someone who knew or ought to have known it was unauthorized, a pattern of similar breaches and breaches the custodian judges significant (O. Reg. 329/04 s. 6.3) The OPC, for every breach that meets the real risk of significant harm test (s. 10.1(1))
Records A report of the previous year's thefts, losses and unauthorized uses and disclosures, due to the IPC on or before March 1 each year (s. 6.4) A record of every breach of security safeguards (PIPEDA s. 10.3(1)), kept for 24 months after the organization determines the breach occurred (SOR/2018-64 s. 6)
Penalties Offence fines up to CAD 200,000 for individuals and CAD 1,000,000 for organizations (PHIPA s. 72(2)); IPC administrative penalties of up to CAD 50,000 for individuals and CAD 500,000 for organizations, which the IPC may increase by any economic benefit gained (O. Reg. 329/04 s. 35) Fines up to CAD 100,000 on indictment for knowingly breaching the breach reporting and record rules (PIPEDA s. 28)

Federal Reform: Where Things Stand

PIPEDA is still in force. Bill C-36, which would enact a Protecting Privacy and Consumer Data Act and amend PIPEDA, was introduced on June 15, 2026 and, as of November 21, 2026, has passed first reading only in the House of Commons, with no second reading debate recorded (LEGISinfo, 2026). We could not confirm how a new federal statute would treat the existing Ontario exemption order; that will depend on the final text.

What to Do Now

  1. Name your custodian. Record whether the custodian is each practitioner or the group practice operator, and who signs vendor agreements.
  2. Map where records leave Ontario. Check where your EMR, backups and email are hosted, and list out of province referral, billing or transcription services. PIPEDA can reappear there.
  3. Sort your vendors. Mark each one as an agent or an electronic service provider, and confirm the contract reflects the use and disclosure limits in O. Reg. 329/04.
  4. Build breach handling to PHIPA's trigger. Every incident gets assessed for patient notice and the seven IPC circumstances, and logged for the March 1 report.
  5. Keep access logs anyway. PHIPA s. 10.1 would require an electronic audit log of every instance a record is viewed, handled or modified, but as of November 21, 2026 the e-Laws consolidation lists it as not in force. Logging who opened which chart is still the best defence against snooping.
  6. Separate non-clinical lines. If you also sell products or run a wellness brand, decide with counsel which law governs that data. Our PIPEDA explainer covers the federal side.

How Cyberphore Can Help

We help Ontario clinics and health practices map where patient data lives, tighten vendor access and build a breach process that fits PHIPA's notice rules. Our privacy compliance service starts with a free scoping call, and pricing is quote-only.

Services for this topic

Share this article

Questions and Answers

Does PIPEDA apply to a doctor's office in Ontario?

Generally not for patient information handled within Ontario. A physician or group practice is a health information custodian under PHIPA, and a federal exemption order removes custodians from PIPEDA for collection, use and disclosure inside the province. PIPEDA can come back into play when information is disclosed outside Ontario, so map where your records travel before assuming only one law applies.

Do we have to report every PHIPA breach to the IPC?

No. Every theft, loss or unauthorized use or disclosure means notifying the affected patients at the first reasonable opportunity. Notice to Ontario's Information and Privacy Commissioner is required only in prescribed situations, such as theft, snooping by someone who knew or ought to have known it was unauthorized, a pattern of similar breaches or a significant breach. All incidents still count toward the annual statistics report due March 1.

Is our EMR or IT provider covered by PHIPA?

Usually, in part. A vendor that acts for your clinic is an agent, and its handling of patient data counts as your clinic's use. A vendor that only supplies electronic services must follow the restrictions in Ontario Regulation 329/04, such as using the information only as the service requires and not disclosing it. Its own customer and marketing data generally falls under PIPEDA.

Is PIPEDA being replaced?

Not yet. Bill C-36, introduced in the House of Commons on June 15, 2026, would enact a new federal private-sector privacy statute. As of November 21, 2026, it has passed first reading only, with no second reading debate recorded, so PIPEDA remains the law. Any change to how the federal law interacts with PHIPA will depend on the final text and future exemption orders.

Sources (9, primary and official first)

  1. Health Information Custodians in the Province of Ontario Exemption Order (SOR/2005-399) (opens in a new tab) · Justice Laws Website, Government of Canada,
  2. Personal Health Information Protection Act, 2004, S.O. 2004, c. 3, Sched. A (opens in a new tab) · Government of Ontario, e-Laws,
  3. O. Reg. 329/04: General (Personal Health Information Protection Act, 2004) (opens in a new tab) · Government of Ontario, e-Laws,
  4. Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act (S.C. 2000, c. 5) (opens in a new tab) · Justice Laws Website, Government of Canada,
  5. Breach of Security Safeguards Regulations (SOR/2018-64) (opens in a new tab) · Justice Laws Website, Government of Canada,
  6. Provincial laws that may apply instead of PIPEDA (opens in a new tab) · Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada,
  7. The Application of PIPEDA to Municipalities, Universities, Schools, and Hospitals (opens in a new tab) · Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada,
  8. Summary of privacy laws in Canada (opens in a new tab) · Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada,
  9. C-36 (45-1): An Act to enact the Protecting Privacy and Consumer Data Act (opens in a new tab) · Parliament of Canada, LEGISinfo,

General information for Canadian organizations, not legal advice.

Written by

Cyberphore Security Team

Certified security analysts and consultants

  • CISSP
  • CISM
  • OSCP
  • OSCE
  • GIAC GCIH
  • GIAC GCIA
  • GIAC GPEN
  • Microsoft SC-200

Articles are researched and written by Cyberphore's security team. Every team member, from analysts to leadership, holds industry certifications, and the team monitors and responds to threats for Canadian organizations 24/7/365. Every article is fact-checked against its sources and reviewed before publishing.

How we research, fact-check and update articles: editorial standards. Spotted an error? Email Use our contact form.

Incident happening now? Our team answers 24/7: +1 236 665 1165

Keep reading

Continue Reading

Book free assessment