For most Canadian SMBs, Microsoft 365 is the business. Email, files, Teams, often the phone system too. That makes the Microsoft 365 account the most valuable thing an attacker can steal, and account takeover is the most common serious incident we see in small businesses.
How Do Attackers Take Over Microsoft 365 Accounts?
| Method | How it works | Does basic MFA stop it? |
|---|---|---|
| Adversary-in-the-middle phishing | A fake login page relays your sign-in and steals the session token | No |
| Password spraying | Common passwords tried against many accounts | Yes, if MFA is enforced on all accounts |
| Infostealer malware | Malware on a home or personal device steals saved passwords and cookies | Often no, because the cookie is already authenticated |
| MFA fatigue | Repeated push prompts until the user taps Approve | Partly; number matching helps |
| Device code phishing | Victim is tricked into entering a code on a real Microsoft page | No |
| Help desk social engineering | Caller convinces IT to reset MFA | No |
The pattern to notice: attackers have adapted to MFA. They no longer need your second factor if they can steal the session that results from it. That is why phishing-resistant MFA and conditional access matter.
What Do Attackers Do Once They Are In?
Usually, they stay quiet. Common actions:
- Create inbox rules that move replies containing "invoice", "payment" or "bank" into an obscure folder.
- Register their own MFA method or authenticator app so they can return.
- Read through mail to learn payment patterns and relationships.
- Send phishing from your real address to your clients and suppliers.
- Download files from OneDrive and SharePoint.
- Grant consent to a malicious app that keeps access even after a password change.
The business impact is usually business email compromise: a client of a Vancouver law firm wires closing funds to a criminal because the instructions came from the firm's real mailbox.
What Are the Warning Signs?
- Sign-ins from countries where you have no staff, or "impossible travel" between two locations.
- New inbox rules, especially ones that delete or move messages.
- A new MFA method registered without the user's knowledge.
- Clients asking about an email you never sent.
- Undeliverable bounces for messages you did not send.
How Do You Prevent a Microsoft 365 Account Takeover?
- Enforce MFA for every user, with no exceptions for executives or shared mailboxes.
- Move admins, and ideally finance, to phishing-resistant MFA such as FIDO2 security keys or passkeys.
- Use conditional access to block legacy authentication, restrict risky countries and require compliant devices. This needs Microsoft Entra ID P1, which is included in Microsoft 365 Business Premium.
- Block users from consenting to third-party apps without admin approval.
- Alert on new inbox forwarding rules and new MFA registrations.
- Have someone actually watch sign-in risk alerts and respond to them.
Our guide to securing Microsoft 365 covers the configuration in more detail, and our Microsoft 365 and email security service handles both setup and monitoring. If you suspect an account is compromised right now, go to What to do if Microsoft 365 is hacked.